כּנור דוד

Kinnor David - "a most attractive blog".

Monday, November 07, 2005

Republic of Dunces?

For another, and perhaps more insightful (and certainly more thoughful and original) view, check out evariste's view at Discarded Lies. I found two of his points to be of particular interest. The first:

The funny thing is that the rioters have learned from the French themselves, and surpassed them-urban terrorism is a time-honored French way to blackmail the state into succumbing to a special interest group's demands. They're just taking France's lawless culture of shameless blackmail to heart. In fact, you could say they're just extraordinarily zealous in their pursuit of a special rider to the standard French social contract. The "racial" angle is too simplistic, and the "Islam" angle is also has insufficient explanatory power. The truth is that this is just business as usual in France, only more so.

The second:

France's real problem with its immigrant population isn't their unwillingness to integrate. It's France's racism and unwillingness to integrate them. These young people aren't new immigrants, most of them were born in France to immigrant parents-they just can't get jobs because of their skin color, their names, and their addresses.

That has the ring of truth, to me. These people are simply not considered "French" no matter how longstanding their connection with the country. It's worth reading the whole piece, which concludes that, for various reasons, not least the government's response to the riots, political Islam will be greatly empowered by the last few days' events.

1 Comments:

Blogger Chip said...

Doesn't everything "empower radical Islam"? If one tries to assimilate Muslims into modern, liberal democracies, so long as the seed of Muslim belief is still within, it is inevitable that some of the 'assimilated' will begin to feel uncomfortable with such 'immorality' as women leaving the house, skirts, you know the drill.

On the other hand, if left to their own devices, Muslims may or may not become radicals depending on their reaction to core Islamic teachings.

The 'West' (proxy word for liberal, secular, democracies) will always seem like a cancer which must be excised so long as the spore of Islamic teaching is waiting to blossom. It's like a philosophical booby trap which could spring at any moment.

The West is completely obsessed with socio-economic analysis. There is some validity to this mode of thinking, but many seem to believe that is the only way to analyze anything. They view the entire world through the cardboard tube of social class, employment, and financial status.

Human beings are not so simple.

I can assure you my grandfather did not give up his congressional pay so he could fight in WWI and, due to a law which was designed to prevent congressmen from looking like cowards, also forfeit his pay as a soldier for socio-economic reasons. He chose to put his body where his mouth demanded he go.

Some people really believe things and money doesn't enter the picture.

1:05 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home